Alps Shootings: Brother Denies ‘Conflict’

The brother of a British computer engineer shot dead in the French Alps has denied being in dispute with the dead man, police said. Saad al Hilli, 50, was slumped over the wheel of his bullet-riddled BMW in an isolated woodland car park near Lake Annecy.

Alps Shootings: Brother Denies 'Conflict'

Alps Shootings: Brother Denies ‘Conflict’

The bodies of his dentist wife Iqbal, 47, and an older Swedish woman were found in the back.

The couple’s four-year-old daughter Zeena laid undiscovered under her mother’s body for eight hours, while her seven-year-old sister Zainab is in an induced coma after being shot and beaten. The body of a French cyclist, Sylvain Mollier, 45, who apparently stumbled across the attack, was found nearby.

Prosecutor Eric Maillaud told a news conference information had come from a police source about a “possible conflict with regard to money matters” between Mr al Hilli and his brother. But he said the brother had told British officers this was not case. He learned of the murders on TV and went to see police to get more information.

He then returned to a police station after reports emerged of a fraternal dispute, telling them: “I have no conflict, no feud, with my brother.” Mr Maillaud said a French detective had flown to the UK to interview him as a witness.

Mr Maillaud also confirmed the identities of the murdered British family, from Claygate, Surrey. He said the information had come from Zeena, who was able to give the first names of her dead parents and her sister. But the little girl did not know the identity of the elderly woman found dead in the car. It was initially reported she was Mr al Hilli’s mother-in-law.

He said Zeena had not seen the attackers. “She didn’t bring anything to the inquiry,” he added. “The little girl was terrorised. She rushed under her mother’s legs. She heard, but she didn’t see anything.”

He also said detectives would get the DNA of the victims in the next few hours. All of the bodies had been shot at least three times – contradicting earlier reports – and 25 bullet cartridges were found at the scene. Earlier, police said 15 were found.

Mr Maillaud said the British cyclist who discovered the bodies did not hear any shots, but saw a green 4X4 car and a motorbike leaving the scene. Police could not confirm whether the killer used a silencer or the type of weapon used. “It’s absolutely useless to tell the killers everything they used, or everything we know,” Mr Maillaud added.

Meanwhile, officers are searching for a driver seen speeding away from the scene, according to Sky sources. Detectives are trying to track down the man, who was wearing a black shirt and driving a white Peugeot 4×4. It is understood the car had to swerve to avoid a woman in another car travelling in the other direction on Wednesday afternoon.

A witness told Sky News: “It was a white car, a small one with a man inside … and I think he was alone. Brown hair, I believe. “No one takes that turn that fast, because there is no visibility, you have to slow down and that was really too fast.” The bodies were found just off the country road.

The British cyclist, a former RAF officer on holiday, also found Zainab, who collapsed in front of him near the car. She had been beaten around the head and shot in the shoulder. She had been fighting for her life in an induced coma at a hospital in the city of Grenoble, but is now in a stable condition. Detectives hope she will recover sufficiently from the trauma to give clues to the killing.

Her sister has been admitted to another Grenoble hospital in “distress” and is receiving psychiatric care. Both girls, who go to school in Claygate, are being guarded by armed police. Mr al Hilli had been working as a freelance engineer for Guildford-based Surrey Satellite Technology after fleeing Saddam Hussein’s Iraq.

He and his family had been staying in a caravan at a campsite popular with UK tourists called Le Solitaire du Lac, in Saint Jorioz, since Monday.No weapons were found at the scene of the shooting, which happened at around 3.40pm on Wednesday.

Police have now re-opened the car park where the attack happened, but despite a lengthy clean-up operation, glass, tyre marks and blood can still be seen at the site. Sky News

  • Kassoul

    A british psychology professor was interviewed about the girls state of mind
    He said the girls have a natural sense of how they see people like caring and human but still do have fear like any other adult or young
    But when a horrific attack happens to them in these circumstance the rosie view about human will disappear and the psychological scare will be there for the rest of their lives
    these two orphans who lost G-mother, mum and dad in front of their eyes don't need to be british to qualify for sympathy, any innocent child deserve empathy and respect.

  • Amie

    Some of the comments regarding the family's race have sickened me beyond belief. Any normal human being would show compassion for two children who have been left orphaned after such a brutal attack. The cyclist's poor family will also be grieving. I would've thought race wouldn't be an issue here; how naive of me to expect an ounce of humanity to be shown by the 'Great British public'. Those of you still banging on about 'immigrants bleeding us dry' should be ashamed of yourselves.

  • Larry

    If the British cyclist was "nearby" when the killings happened you would have though he'd have heard some of the many gun-shots, but there has been no mention of this. Perhaps it was a contract killing by a hitman who used a silenced weapon?

  • Bill

    The suggestion of a family dispute may simply be intended to divert public attention from what has really been going on. There is something not right about all this and it would be very wrong to jump to any conclusions.

  • Day

    You're right, it's just fishy and not making sense. How did that RAF guy happen to be there at that time yet not hear any gunshots a few moments before when those gunshots were hard at the campsite. And he's the only witness at the scene, I don't get it :-s

  • Michael

    C4 news said he was part of an aerial photography company, and showed pics of the building but had no information other than company records.

  • Cassy

    Those poor children, to see you parents and grandma shot, must have been terrifying. They will be scarred for life. I hope they have a someone close who can help them rebuild their young lives. Bless them xxx

  • Kassoul

    It looks like a contract killing
    Police said it was a professional act. all shot in the front head. and on the face
    from outside thru the windows.
    The 8 yrs girl was sitting in front when her father was shot she got out of the car and run the killer killed her Gmother and went on the other side shot the mother and the girl who run away she was hit on the shoulder and he went to her and beat her to the head with the gun some 6-7 hard blow to the skull the cyclist appeared the killer went to him and shot the last victim.
    he may have run of bullets or was cautious someone else will turn up.he sped away in his car
    the injured girl was heading back to the car and about to faint when the second cyclist appeared and saw her about to faint.

    The police thinks it is a complicated murder
    I don't think it is a racist or a burglary gone wrong
    it goes a bit higer than that
    All the indications points to a contract killing
    if that is assumed who benefits from it ?

  • Abdul

    After reading the various news reports, I would say this was a professional assassination by someone who is very experienced in this kind of work. consequently it's most unlikely the killer/s will be brought to justice. One of these type of murders, which was drug related, happened quite close to where I live about three years ago and the killers have never been found.

  • Olive

    It looks like assassination, it doesn't look like a robbery…… Poor little girls they will carry this bad moment of their life forever….hope the people who did this will never have a good day to the rest of their life…..

  • XYZ

    Kids normally have photography memories. Hope, one of the daughter will remember killer(s) face(s)